imbad0202__academic-research-skills/examples/pi/state/pipeline-state.json

{
  "topic": "臺灣少子化對私立大學招生策略之影響",
  "language": "zh-Hant",
  "bilingual_abstract": true,
  "pipeline_version": "3.19.0",
  "entry_point": "1",
  "current_stage": "6",
  "pipeline_state": "completed",
  "pipeline_completed_at": "2026-08-03T18:19:42Z",
  "consecutive_continue_count": 0,
  "round_trip_budget": {
    "estimated_max": 36,
    "accumulated": 36,
    "advisory_only": true
  },
  "stages": {
    "1": {"name": "RESEARCH", "skill": "deep-research", "status": "completed", "mode": "socratic-to-full-investigation", "subphase": "stage1_complete", "outputs": ["Research Question Brief v1", "Methodology Blueprint v1", "Socratic INSIGHT Collection v1", "Devil's Advocate Checkpoint 1 v1: PASS", "Phase 1 Artifact Index v1", "Phase 2 Search Protocol v1", "Annotated Bibliography and Search Strategy v1", "Source Verification Report v1: PASS WITH BOUNDED EVIDENCE", "Phase 2 Artifact Index v1", "Phase 3 Synthesis Report v1", "Devil's Advocate Checkpoint 2 v1: PASS", "Phase 3 Artifact Index v1", "Phase 4 Research Report Draft v1", "Phase 4 Artifact Index v1", "Phase 5 Editorial Review v1: MINOR REVISION", "Phase 5 Ethics Review v1: CONDITIONAL", "Devil's Advocate Checkpoint 3 v1: REVISE", "Phase 5 Artifact Index v1", "Phase 6 Revised Research Report v1", "Phase 6 Revision Log v1", "Checkpoint 3 Recheck v1: PASS", "Phase 6 Artifact Index v1", "Stage 1 Collaboration Depth Observation: INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE"], "checkpoint_type": "deep-research_phase6_completion", "checkpoint_confirmed": true, "phase2_started_at": "2026-08-03T05:57:57Z", "phase2_completed_at": "2026-08-03T06:36:08Z", "phase2_confirmed_at": "2026-08-03T06:41:53Z", "phase3_started_at": "2026-08-03T06:41:53Z", "phase3_completed_at": "2026-08-03T06:49:52Z", "phase3_confirmed_at": "2026-08-03T06:53:30Z", "phase4_started_at": "2026-08-03T06:53:30Z", "phase4_completed_at": "2026-08-03T07:00:41Z", "phase4_confirmed_at": "2026-08-03T07:08:50Z", "phase5_started_at": "2026-08-03T07:08:50Z", "phase5_execution_mode": "sequential_single_pi_session_disclosed", "phase5_completed_at": "2026-08-03T07:14:32Z", "phase5_verdicts": {"editorial": "MINOR_REVISION", "ethics": "CONDITIONAL", "devils_advocate_checkpoint_3": "REVISE"}, "checkpoint3_confirmed_at": "2026-08-03T07:20:41Z", "phase6_started_at": "2026-08-03T07:20:41Z", "length_target_correction": "approximately_6000_Chinese_characters_not_word_equivalence", "funding_conflict_declaration": "no_external_funding_and_no_named_employment_governance_consulting_or_commercial_conflict", "phase6_completed_at": "2026-08-03T07:33:43Z", "phase6_revision_loops_used": 1, "checkpoint3_recheck_verdict": "PASS", "stage1_confirmed_at": "2026-08-03T07:36:51Z", "stage1_collaboration_observer": "insufficient_evidence_raw_dialogue_compacted_non_blocking"},
    "2": {"name": "WRITE", "skill": "academic-paper", "status": "completed", "mode": "plan-to-full", "subphase": "stage2_complete", "outputs": ["Stage 1 to Stage 2 Handoff v1", "Paper Configuration Record Plan Mode v1", "Proposed Paper Outline and Evidence Allocation v1", "Stage 2 Planning Artifact Index v1", "Outline Approval Record v1", "Argument Blueprint v1", "Argument Builder Artifact Index v1", "Draft Writer Precommitment v1", "Draft Writer Phase 4b Output v1", "Citation Compliance Report v1", "Bilingual Abstract and Check v1", "Complete Stage 2 Course Paper Draft v1", "Stage 2 Draft Checkpoint Index v1"], "started_at": "2026-08-03T07:36:51Z", "planning_completed_at": "2026-08-03T07:42:32Z", "outline_checkpoint_confirmed": true, "outline_confirmed_at": "2026-08-03T07:54:56Z", "argument_blueprint_completed_at": "2026-08-03T07:54:56Z", "argument_checkpoint_confirmed": true, "argument_confirmed_at": "2026-08-03T07:59:18Z", "drafting_started": true, "draft_writer_execution_mode": "sequential_single_pi_session_with_degraded_paper_blind_precommitment_disclosed", "draft_completed_at": "2026-08-03T08:11:39Z", "citation_check": "PASS_WITH_DISCLOSED_FLAGS", "abstract_check": "PASS", "stage2_checkpoint_confirmed": true, "stage2_confirmed_at": "2026-08-03T08:15:42Z"},
    "2.5": {"name": "INTEGRITY", "agent": "integrity_verification_agent", "status": "completed", "mode": "pre-review", "subphase": "stage2_5_complete", "outputs": ["Academic Integrity Verification Report Round 1: FAIL", "Reference Adjudication v1", "Citation Context Audit v1", "Claim Registry and Verification v1", "Page Provenance Map v1", "Temporal Audit v1", "Corrected Pre-review Course Paper v1", "Integrity Correction Log v1", "Focused Re-verification Report Round 2: PASS", "AI Research Failure Mode Checklist: 7/7 CLEAR", "Compliance Report Schema 12: WARN", "Stage 2.5 Round 2 Artifact Index v1"], "started_at": "2026-08-03T08:15:42Z", "round1_completed_at": "2026-08-03T09:22:24Z", "round1_verdict": "FAIL", "correction_rounds_used": 1, "round2_completed_at": "2026-08-03T09:35:50Z", "round2_verdict": "PASS", "compliance_decision": "WARN_NON_BLOCKING_OTHER_EVIDENCE_SYNTHESIS", "compliance_warn_acknowledged": true, "failure_mode_checklist": "PASS_7_OF_7_CLEAR", "serious_issues": 0, "medium_issues": 0, "minor_issues": 0, "resolved_issue_ids": ["IL-MEDIUM-1", "IL-MINOR-1", "ADV-TEMP-1"], "review_input": "stage-02.5-integrity-pre-review/02-corrected-pre-review-course-paper.md", "confirmed_at": "2026-08-03T09:41:18Z", "checkpoint_confirmed": true},
    "3": {"name": "REVIEW", "skill": "academic-paper-reviewer", "status": "completed", "mode": "full", "subphase": "stage3_complete_strategy_confirmed", "outputs": ["Stage 2.5 to Stage 3 Handoff v1", "Field Analysis and Reviewer Configuration v1", "Phase 0 Artifact Index v1", "Reviewer Configuration Approval Record v1", "Journal-Fit Review Report v1", "Methodology Review Report v1", "Domain Review Report v1", "Perspective Review Report v1", "Devil's Advocate Review Report v1", "Editorial Decision and Revision Roadmap v1: MAJOR REVISION", "Machine Revision Roadmap v1", "Panel Execution and Validation Report v1", "Stage 3 Review Artifact Index v1", "Stage 3 Decision Approval and Coaching Intake v1", "Socratic Revision Coaching Progress v1", "Scholar-Formulated Revision Strategy v1", "Reprioritized Revision Roadmap v1", "Coaching Completion and Strategy Checkpoint v1"], "started_at": "2026-08-03T09:41:18Z", "immutable_review_input": "stage-02.5-integrity-pre-review/02-corrected-pre-review-course-paper.md", "immutable_review_input_sha256": "867ab46797b7270fdbe3edb8814fa24cfe1712a2aa8ceb09f27b7cbcee320d76", "panel_execution_mode": "sequential_same_pi_context_no_independent_windows_disclosed", "reviewer_configuration_confirmed": true, "reviewer_configuration_confirmed_at": "2026-08-03T09:45:00Z", "sprint_contract": "reviewer/reviewer_full/v2", "panel_size": 5, "usable_panel_reports": 5, "phase_conformance": "PASS_5_OF_5", "panel_synthesis_check": "PASS_FIRST_ATTEMPT", "dimension_verdicts": {"D1": "block", "D2": "warn", "D3": "block", "D4": "warn", "D5": "warn", "D6": "block"}, "fired_conditions": ["F2", "F3", "F5"], "editorial_decision": "Major Revision", "editorial_decision_confirmed": true, "editorial_decision_confirmed_at": "2026-08-03T10:02:31Z", "da_critical_count": 0, "must_fix_items": 4, "review_completed_at": "2026-08-03T09:59:41Z", "revision_coaching_started_at": "2026-08-03T10:02:31Z", "revision_coaching_round": 5, "revision_coaching_expected_rounds": 5, "revision_coaching_completed_at": "2026-08-03T10:25:47Z", "revision_posture": "measurement_core_scope_stratification_prototype_demotion", "required_revision_order": ["R1", "R2", "R4", "R3"], "new_literature_search_allowed": false, "revision_strategy_confirmed": true, "revision_strategy_confirmed_at": "2026-08-03T10:29:11Z", "stage4_started": true, "checkpoint_confirmed": true},
    "4": {"name": "REVISE", "skill": "academic-paper", "status": "completed_and_scholar_confirmed", "mode": "revision_patch", "subphase": "stage4_complete", "outputs": ["Stage 3 to Stage 4 Handoff v1", "Anchored Pre-revision Base v1", "Revision Writer Precommitment v1", "Revision Patch Round 1 v1", "Deterministic Apply Report Round 1 v1", "Revision Patch Round 2 v1", "Deterministic Apply Report Round 2 v1", "Revision Patch Round 3 v1", "Deterministic Apply Report Round 3 v1", "Revised Course Paper for Inspection v1", "Response to Reviewers Schema 8 v1", "Response to Reviewers Human Report v1", "Apply Chain Manifest v1", "Stage 4 Validation Report v1", "Complete Revision Diff v1", "Stage 4 Artifact Index and Checkpoint v1"], "started_at": "2026-08-03T10:29:11Z", "completed_at": "2026-08-03T10:44:48Z", "revision_posture": "measurement_core_scope_stratification_prototype_demotion", "required_revision_order": ["R1", "R2", "R4", "R3"], "new_literature_search_run": false, "patch_rounds": 3, "structural_flags": false, "full_reemission": false, "apply_chain_pass": true, "patch_digest_binding_pass": true, "final_revised_manuscript": "stage-04-revision/09-revised-course-paper-for-inspection.md", "final_revised_manuscript_sha256": "ac17240daedee845185f875d395e6e03aa7d44981ce99b1a52c61d6c5461f3b7", "response_coverage": "10_OF_10", "resolved_items": 9, "deliberate_limitations": 1, "new_references": 0, "citation_check": "PASS_58_MARKERS_58_ANCHORS_21_SOURCES_21_REFERENCES", "data_reproduction": "PASS_UNCHANGED_OUTPUT_HASH", "latest_preserved_ratio": 0.9828, "cumulative_original_block_preserved_ratio": 0.7928, "main_section_cjk_characters": 6966, "stage3p_started": true, "checkpoint_confirmed": true, "confirmed_by": "scholar_resume_instruction", "confirmed_at": "2026-08-03T15:35:22Z"},
    "3p": {"name": "RE-REVIEW", "skill": "academic-paper-reviewer", "status": "completed_decision_confirmed", "mode": "re-review", "subphase": "stage3p_decision_checkpoint", "outputs": ["Frozen Round-1 Findings Bundle v1", "Hash-bound Input Manifest v1", "Phase 1 Precommitment v1", "Phase 1 Gate Record v1", "Phase 2A Verdict Record v1", "Phase 2A Gate Record v1", "Phase 2B Traceability Sidecar v1", "Phase 2B Gate and Checker Record v1", "Verification Review Report v1: MAJOR REVISION", "Residual Revision Roadmap v1", "Stage 3p Artifact Index and Mandatory Checkpoint v1"], "started_at": "2026-08-03T13:33:53Z", "transport_recovery_resumed_at": "2026-08-03T15:35:22Z", "completed_at": "2026-08-03T15:35:22Z", "execution_mode": "sequential_same_pi_context_disclosed_transport_recovery", "independent_reviewers_claimed": false, "cross_model_active": false, "round1_cards_reused": true, "field_analyst_rerun": false, "input_manifest_validation": "PASS", "apply_chain_witness": "pass", "phase1_schema_lint": "PASS", "phase2a_schema_lint": "PASS", "phase2b_schema_lint": "PASS", "synthesis_checker": "PASS_EXIT_0", "revised_manuscript_sha256": "ac17240daedee845185f875d395e6e03aa7d44981ce99b1a52c61d6c5461f3b7", "input_manifest_jcs_sha256": "f6c8fea09db783758bb8273e385d72831048a6dc8172c6a5450d2c24b1aa26be", "precommitment_jcs_sha256": "263148e3cd0edbee8a92bf3ab26b9cfe9a67c93003adc5ea3b59cd5ea354bb30", "verdict_record_jcs_sha256": "d4f844eca0f4bd94b7695bbf18fcc57df95887c0c3b3afea35dc1cb8e8d91f0b", "traceability_jcs_sha256": "1d323000086d11a01ddd33211dcb726a645356f3dc59e259e1ded10ef059292d", "must_fix_verdicts": {"fully_addressed": 3, "partially_addressed": 1, "not_addressed": 0, "made_worse": 0, "cannot_verify": 0}, "should_fix_verdicts": {"fully_addressed": 4, "partially_addressed": 1, "not_addressed": 0, "made_worse": 0, "cannot_verify": 0}, "p2_addressed_rate": "5_OF_5", "new_issues": 0, "regressions": 0, "decision_rule": "B4", "decision": "Major Revision", "reject_recommended": false, "checkpoint_type": "MANDATORY", "checkpoint_confirmed": true, "decision_accepted": true, "confirmed_at": "2026-08-03T16:38:00Z", "coaching_skipped_by_scholar": true},
    "4p": {"name": "RE-REVISE", "skill": "academic-paper", "status": "completed_and_scholar_confirmed", "mode": "revision_patch", "subphase": "stage4p_inspection_checkpoint", "outputs": ["Stage 3p to Stage 4p Handoff v1", "Anchored Pre-rerevision Base v1", "Revision Writer Precommitment v1", "Focused Revision Patch v1", "Deterministic Apply Report v1", "Re-revised Course Paper for Inspection v1", "Stage 4p Response to Re-review v1", "Focused Patch Apply Record v1", "Stage 4p Validation Report v1", "Focused Revision Diff v1", "Token Conservation Advisory ADV-REV-1", "Stage 4p Artifact Index and Inspection Checkpoint v1"], "started_at": "2026-08-03T16:38:00Z", "completed_at": "2026-08-03T16:38:00Z", "execution_mode": "sequential_same_pi_context_disclosed_transport_recovery", "independent_writer_or_evaluator_claimed": false, "coaching_skipped_by_scholar": true, "authorized_scope": ["REV-3P-001"], "preserved_limitation": "REV-3P-002", "new_literature_search_run": false, "patch_rounds": 1, "ops": 1, "changed_blocks": ["B0031"], "preserved_limitation_blocks": ["B0070", "B0116"], "structural_flags": false, "full_reemission": false, "apply_chain_pass": true, "patch_digest_binding_pass": true, "base_sha256": "ac17240daedee845185f875d395e6e03aa7d44981ce99b1a52c61d6c5461f3b7", "final_rerevised_manuscript": "stage-04p-rerevision/03-re-revised-course-paper-for-inspection.md", "final_rerevised_manuscript_sha256": "513004b245efe8a557e92144faa8c06eb6bd95e16095d35a624d3d7d4870e40f", "preserved_ratio": 0.9914, "blocks_preserved_byte_identical": "115_OF_116", "rev_3p_001_status": "RESOLVED_PENDING_SCHOLAR_INSPECTION", "rev_3p_002_status": "DELIBERATE_LIMITATION_PRESERVED", "citation_anchor_stream": "UNCHANGED", "new_references": 0, "token_conservation_advisories": ["ADV-REV-1"], "stage4_5_started": true, "checkpoint_type": "FULL", "checkpoint_confirmed": true, "confirmed_at": "2026-08-03T16:45:37Z", "scholar_inspected_artifacts": ["focused_diff", "response", "patch_apply_record", "validation_report", "checkpoint"], "accepted_advisories": ["ADV-REV-1"]},
    "4.5": {"name": "FINAL INTEGRITY", "agent": "integrity_verification_agent", "status": "completed_pass_and_scholar_confirmed", "mode": "final-check", "subphase": "stage4_5_complete", "outputs": ["Final Integrity Input and Precommitment v1", "Fresh Reference Adjudication v1", "Data Reproduction Log v1", "Full Citation Context Audit v1", "Full Claim Registry and Verification v1", "Originality Audit v1", "E6 Claim Strength Audit v1", "Retraction Correction Check v1", "AI Research Failure Mode Checklist v1: 7/7 CLEAR", "Compliance Report Schema 12 v1: WARN", "Figure Table and Experiment Audit v1", "Scope Novelty and Traceability Audit v1", "Token Advisory Register v1", "Final Integrity Verification Report v1: PASS", "Final Verified Course Paper v1", "Stage 4.5 Artifact Index and Mandatory Checkpoint v1"], "started_at": "2026-08-03T16:45:37Z", "completed_at": "2026-08-03T17:28:28Z", "verification_input": "stage-04p-rerevision/03-re-revised-course-paper-for-inspection.md", "verification_input_sha256": "513004b245efe8a557e92144faa8c06eb6bd95e16095d35a624d3d7d4870e40f", "final_verified_manuscript": "stage-04.5-final-integrity/14-final-verified-course-paper.md", "final_verified_manuscript_sha256": "513004b245efe8a557e92144faa8c06eb6bd95e16095d35a624d3d7d4870e40f", "verdict": "PASS", "blocking_issues": 0, "serious_issues": 0, "medium_issues": 0, "minor_correction_items": 0, "execution_mode": "sequential_same_pi_context_disclosed_transport_recovery", "independent_verifier_claimed": false, "new_literature_search_run": false, "verification_only_live_lookups_run": true, "corpus_changed": false, "cross_model_active": false, "claim_audit_opt_in": false, "references_checked": 21, "references_verified": 21, "citation_contexts_checked": 58, "citation_contexts_verified": 58, "claims_checked": 41, "claims_verified": 41, "data_reproduction": "PASS_UNCHANGED_HASH", "originality_sampling": "24_OF_46_52.17_PERCENT_ALL_REVISED", "temporal_findings": 0, "e4_advisories": 0, "e5_advisories": 0, "e6_advisories": 0, "token_conservation_advisories": {"total": 12, "accepted": 12, "open_nonblocking": 0}, "ai_failure_mode_checklist": "PASS_7_OF_7_CLEAR", "compliance_decision": "WARN_NONBLOCKING_OTHER_EVIDENCE_SYNTHESIS", "compliance_acknowledgement_pending": false, "compliance_warn_acknowledged": true, "compliance_warn_disposition": "preserve_as_reporting_limitation_no_silent_manuscript_expansion", "stage5_entry_confirmed_at": "2026-08-03T17:38:02Z", "citation_style_selected": "APA_7_TRADITIONAL_CHINESE_ADAPTATION", "all_token_advisories_accepted_at": "2026-08-03T17:38:02Z", "stage3p_traceability_sidecar_consumed": true, "stage3p_frozen_new_issues": {"previously_missed": 0, "indeterminate": 0}, "stage5_started": true, "checkpoint_type": "MANDATORY", "checkpoint_confirmed": true},
    "5": {"name": "FINALIZE", "skill": "academic-paper", "status": "completed_and_scholar_confirmed", "mode": "format-convert", "subphase": "stage5_complete", "outputs": ["Stage 4.5 to Stage 5 Handoff and Format Precommitment v1", "Provenance-finalized Working Draft v1: LOW-WARN", "Human-read Attestation Checklist v1", "Cite-time Hard Gate Record v1: REFUSE", "Cite-time Provenance Gate Report v1: REFUSE", "Human-read Ledger v1: 21 full-text attestations", "Provenance-finalized Working Draft v2: 79/79 ok", "Resolved Human-read Checklist v1", "Cite-time Hard Gate Record v2: PASS", "Clean APA 7 Markdown v1", "APA 7 DOCX v1", "Markdown/DOCX Format Validation v1", "Provenance Summary v1", "Submission Package Verification Report v1: ADVISORY", "Stage 5 Output Package and FULL Completion Checkpoint v1"], "started_at": "2026-08-03T17:38:02Z", "verified_input": "stage-04.5-final-integrity/14-final-verified-course-paper.md", "verified_input_sha256": "513004b245efe8a557e92144faa8c06eb6bd95e16095d35a624d3d7d4870e40f", "citation_style": "APA_7_TRADITIONAL_CHINESE_ADAPTATION", "format_only": true, "source_mutated": false, "formatter_execution_mode": "sequential_same_recovered_pi_context_no_subagent_facility", "independent_formatter_claimed": false, "cite_time_gate": "PASS", "cite_time_gate_reason": null, "anchors": "79_OF_79_SECTION_NON_NONE", "stage4_5_reference_adjudication": "21_OF_21_VERIFIED", "passport_literature_corpus_present": false, "human_read_log_present": true, "human_read_log": "state/material-passport_human_read_log.yaml", "human_read_log_sha256": "6e2b0443ac75513745d0c5e51136809dfbfd15c7f7c652f002b00c58a582ffda", "human_read_scope": "full_text_21_OF_21", "human_read_inferred_from_integrity_report_inspection": false, "citation_marker_resolution": "79_OF_79_OK", "clean_markdown": "stage-05-finalize/02-final-paper-apa7.md", "clean_markdown_sha256": "64ac9f2d5794f1f920136259869fe6a8f4c248f74a5d052f8d349818796ad219", "docx": "stage-05-finalize/03-final-paper-apa7.docx", "docx_sha256": "23740f600c870235efcf8a58b6ea4c3a5b79720f06e91f1d9af24e3639cf728a", "converted_outputs_emitted": true, "latex_question_asked": true, "latex_decision": "DECLINED_BY_SCHOLAR", "paper_pdf_generated": false, "content_confirmation_pending": false, "content_confirmed": true, "content_confirmed_at": "2026-08-03T18:02:56Z", "submission_package_policy": "advisory", "submission_package_verifier": "NO_TERMINAL_TOKEN_7_NOT_CHECKED", "submission_package_report": "stage-05-finalize/package/submission_verification_report.json", "submission_package_report_sha256": "0b665fe42c65bc966b081fc4eb1df7e8cd1b6c28317fde65232fabc71187c815", "submission_verifier_passport_snapshot": "stage-05-finalize/submission-verifier-passport-snapshot.yaml", "submission_verifier_passport_snapshot_sha256": "a59dbfcefc386729d9ea60bf581888098f10682e2bc0e8d15258f9767be5080c", "package_provenance_sha256": "ae39019e659865e244e9a5fa7c3460bd2f87954d8acbb46e3402e0e3dd2e75e9", "completed_at": "2026-08-03T18:02:56Z", "checkpoint_type": "FULL", "checkpoint_confirmed": true, "checkpoint_confirmed_at": "2026-08-03T18:02:56Z", "stage6_authorized": true},
    "6": {"name": "PROCESS SUMMARY", "skill": "academic-pipeline", "status": "completed", "mode": "auto", "subphase": "terminal_confirmed", "outputs": ["Stage 5 to Stage 6 Handoff v1", "Whole-pipeline Collaboration Depth Trajectory v1", "English Paper Creation Process Record MD v1", "English Paper Creation Process Record LaTeX v1", "English Paper Creation Process Record PDF v1", "Traditional Chinese Paper Creation Process Record MD v1", "Traditional Chinese Paper Creation Process Record LaTeX v1", "Traditional Chinese Paper Creation Process Record PDF v1", "Stage 6 Process Record Validation v1", "Stage 6 Artifact Index and Terminal Checkpoint v1", "Terminal Acknowledgement Record v1"], "started_at": "2026-08-03T18:02:56Z", "deliverables_generated_at": "2026-08-03T18:13:01Z", "language_choice": "BOTH_DEFAULT_ENGLISH_FIRST", "raw_dialogue_sessions": 2, "raw_dialogue_user_turns": 41, "raw_dialogue_assistant_text_turns": 37, "execution_mode": "sequential_same_recovered_pi_context_no_independent_observer", "cross_model_active": false, "collaboration_depth": {"delegation_intensity": 8, "cognitive_vigilance": 9, "cognitive_reallocation": 9, "zone": "Zone_3_Deep", "blocking": false}, "collaboration_quality_score": 91, "ai_self_reflection_sycophancy_screen": "HIGH_MECHANICAL_2_OF_2_DA_CONCESSIONS_NOT_DIAGNOSTIC", "failure_mode_history": "7_OF_7_CLEAR_NO_OVERRIDES", "english_process_markdown": "stage-06-process-summary/paper_creation_process_en.md", "english_process_markdown_sha256": "d378ec4100d64c2041083352af09a4d1b5f0acfb778ec047590d310a861f7ea3", "english_process_pdf": "stage-06-process-summary/paper_creation_process_en.pdf", "english_process_pdf_sha256": "d9516715dfb739fb6d84c9d46b5c99e30dad1f53c4db6bd9e64059e1e4a493cd", "traditional_chinese_process_markdown": "stage-06-process-summary/paper_creation_process.md", "traditional_chinese_process_markdown_sha256": "99c4e49ec6cd1a73dbdb0caaee1abfadf556bc7cd5ee44d00077e8d2925ef4a7", "traditional_chinese_process_pdf": "stage-06-process-summary/paper_creation_process_zh.pdf", "traditional_chinese_process_pdf_sha256": "32262fc11e64001d3aadd383e7d41db9abfa33199b06229e0b486b07eaa17e99", "font_fallback": "Songti_TC_for_Source_Han_Serif_TC_VF_unavailable", "checkpoint_type": "TERMINAL", "checkpoint_confirmed": true, "checkpoint_confirmed_at": "2026-08-03T18:19:42Z", "terminal_acknowledgement_received": true, "terminal_acknowledgement_received_at": "2026-08-03T18:19:42Z", "terminal_acknowledgement_record": "stage-06-process-summary/04-terminal-acknowledgement-record.md", "terminal_acknowledgement_record_sha256": "e2c2d90254e9ebfdaa9e9f6f6ecede11ada3e9e843aa36d75deea700177ac31c", "warnings_and_limitations_accepted": true, "completed_at": "2026-08-03T18:19:42Z"}
  },
  "evidence_boundary": {
    "literature_policy_analysis": true,
    "secondary_public_data_only_if_retrieved_and_verified": true,
    "secondary_official_data_descriptive_extraction_completed": true,
    "interviews_conducted": false,
    "original_dataset_analyzed": false,
    "experiments_declared": false,
    "future_mixed_methods_only": true,
    "preserve_unverified_markers": true
  }
}