Files
Michał Pierzchała 480e3883b1 fix(daemon): reject unarmed close --save-script before teardown (#1558)
* fix(daemon): reject unarmed close --save-script before teardown

Live evidence (2026-08-02) showed a plain `open` followed by `close
--save-script` silently published a script: the close request armed
authoring at record time and published moments later in the same
request, folding the never-armed case into the ADR 0016 authoring
lifecycle. The resulting .ad carries selector fallback chains but no
recording-time target-v1 evidence, and nothing told the caller
evidence capture never ran — degraded replay verification with no
signal beats a loud refusal.

`assertTerminalRecordingCloseAllowed` (src/daemon/handlers/session-close.ts)
now rejects an unarmed `close --save-script` with INVALID_ARGS before
any teardown or filesystem work runs, the same seam that already
rejected ABORTED/PUBLISHED terminal recordings. The rejection does not
tear the session down, so a plain `close` retry still completes
cleanly; recovery names `open --save-script` since evidence can only
be captured from action zero. Repair transactions (ADR 0012) are a
disjoint lifecycle and are explicitly unaffected.

This is distinct from #1533 (an already-armed-then-aborted session
whose flag ingress re-enables recordSession and lets a *bare* close
publish); that case remains open.

* fix: review follow-ups for #1558 (help text, test strength, docs)

- Give replay --save-script its own help text instead of the shared
  open/close "arm on open, publish on close" description: replay's flag
  arms an ADR 0012 repair transaction, a disjoint lifecycle. Adds
  CommandSchema.flagDescriptionOverrides so a command can swap a shared
  flag's usageDescription without duplicating the FlagDefinition entry
  (which would have shown --save-script twice in `help replay`). Pinned
  in src/cli/parser/__tests__/cli-help-command-usage.test.ts (open/close
  keep the shared text unchanged; replay gets the new one).

- Strengthen the never-armed close --save-script regression test in
  session-close-shutdown.test.ts: the fixture now carries real
  cleanup-bearing state (an active iOS simulator recording, reusing
  makeIosSimulatorRecordingSession/recordingKillMock) with spies proving
  no teardown hook (recorder kill, runner stop) runs on the rejected
  request, then that a follow-up plain close does tear it down. The
  prior fixture had nothing for teardown to observably touch, so moving
  the guard after stopBestEffortSessionResources would have passed it
  silently. Also fixes a latent test-isolation leak this exposed: an
  earlier test set a persistent mockStopIosRunnerSession rejection
  (vi.clearAllMocks() clears call history, not implementations), which
  would have poisoned any later Apple-platform close test; scoped it to
  mockRejectedValueOnce.

- Point the migration guide (website/docs/docs/migrating-gestures.md) at
  `open --save-script` → interact → `close` instead of the now-rejected
  `open` → interact → `close --save-script`, matching the new guard and
  the corrected help text.

_Generated by [Claude Code](https://claude.ai/code)_
2026-08-03 09:10:40 +02:00
..